CD Review: For This Time (Tribute Quartet)

Tribute Quartet started three or four years ago. Their first two recordings were on BSA World Records; Tribute Quartet was booked by the Beckie Simmons Agency at the time. Those albums were produced by Beckie Simmons Bates’ husband Glen Bates, and most of the songs on both albums were penned by Bates.

Last year found Tribute taking a somewhat different direction, signing with the Harper Agency for booking and with Crossroads Records as their record label. For This Time was produced by Roger Talley and features twelve songs from twelve writers / co-writers. Interestingly, eight of the eleven tracks are from Daywind writers, and only three from Crossroads music publishing. Crossroads doesn’t appear to insist that its artists record its songs, instead taking the approach that its artist record the best songs possible, and that approach pays off on a recording like this.

Tenor Brian Alvey wrote “I Heard It, I Believe It” and co-wrote “That’s Why I Love Him So” with lead singer / manager Gary Casto. Babara Huffman, who co-wrote the Hoppers hit “Grace Will Always Be Greater Than Sin” with Gary Casto, contributed “Calvary Wins Again,” a big ballad featuring bass Dennis Dugger and tenor Brian Alvey. Ronnie Hinson contributed two songs, “He Said That” and “His Tomb is Empty.” The album’s opening track, “I Love Living in Grace,” was written by Rodney Griffin. It was also cut by Liberty Quartet on their 2009 project The Journey.

“He Was In Charge,” a convention-style track, is credited to Kyla Rowland. According to Kyla’s solo album Reminders, on which the song was also cut, it was co-written by Kyla and Dianne Wilkinson.

The album is closed by a bonus track, a live rendition of “Who am I” featuring tenor Brian Alvey. The only lineup change Tribute Quartet has had was when Jacob Kitson left to join Greater Vision and Brian Alvey took his place. Alvey, who had sung previously with Southern Sound, is a top-level talent and does an excellent job on this song, “Calvary Wins Again,” and his other solos.

Highlights include the big ballads “Calvary Wins Again” and “I Am Healed,” and the first radio single, “That’s Why I Love Him So.”  The latter features solos by Casto and Alvey and is a delightfully mellow track with a powerful lyric.

The new producing and songwriting team makes this Tribute Quartet’s best project yet.

Rating: 4 stars. ♦ Average song rating: 3.9 stars. ♦ Group members: Brian Alvey (tenor); Gary Casto (lead); Josh Singletary (baritone/pianist); Dennis Dugger (bass). ♦ Produced by: Roger Talley. ♦ Available from: Label, Artist. Review copy provided. ♦ Song list: I Love Living in Grace; I’ve Been Blessed; Calvary Wins Again; That’s Why I Love Him So; He Said That; That’s What Makes Grace Amazing; His Tomb is Empty; Helpless Not Hopeless; He Was In Charge; I Heard It, I Believe It; I Am Healed; Who Am I.

For more about —and other Southern Gospel news and commentary—follow our RSS feed or sign up for our email updates!

4 Letters to the Editor

Southern Gospel Journal welcomes letters to the editor. We will post the most thoughtful and insightful submissions. Ground rules: Don't attack or belittle groups or fellow posters, or advance heresies rejected by orthodox Christianity. Do keep comments positive, constructive, and on topic.
  1. Thanks for this review, Daniel. This is one of my favorite albums right now and I particularly like That’s Why I Love Him So. By the way, it’s “His Tomb Is Empty” (’cause my heart is full!) instead of “His Tomb Is Not Empty!”

    • OOPS! I’ll go fix that immediately!

  2. Daniel, thank you for your positive comments about ‘Calvary Wins Again.’ That is a very special song to me and Tribute did a great job on it. A bit of trivia is that this song was not pitched to any other artist. I sang it over the phone to Gary and he put it on hold on the spot. Roger Talley’s touch made it even more special. And there was a clerical error made when Dianne Wilkinson’s publishing company sent their song pitch to the group. Dianne did indeed write the lyrics to ‘He Was In Charge.’ Kyla wrote the music.

    • That is neat!

      Also, thanks for the information on the clerical error.

      I love it when Dianne Wilkinson & Kyla Rowland co-write. They come up with some great stuff!


  1. CD Review: The Waiting is Over (Tribute Quartet) | - [...] Tribute Quartet launched several years ago with Jacob Kitson singing the tenor part. Given the name he has made…