SG vs. CCM on YouTube

My recent post about Southern Gospel videos on Amazon’s bestseller list prompted the question of how hits on Southern Gospel videos on YouTube compare to hits on CCM videos. Admittedly, I don’t have the time for a formal study, but I did a simple comparison with the top 5 videos that come up under the keywords “Gaither” and “Casting Crowns.”

Top 5 – Casting Crowns

  1. Who am I Casting Crowns (1,352,999 views) – youth group dramatization of song
  2. Who am I (433,678 views) – audio track of song with slide show of photos
  3. Casting Crowns Who Am I (323,397 views) – two group members do the songgroup sings song on a TV show
  4. casting crowns – if We are the Body (318,524 views) – audio track of song with a slide show of photos
  5. Praise You in this Storm (294,300 views) – audio track of song with a slide show of photos

Top 5 – Gaither

  1. If My Nose was Running Money by Aaron Wilburn (2,756,204 views) – not quite sure why this one came up
  2. Amazing Grace History by Wentley Phipps (1,653,479 views) – song / story from Gaither Homecoming
  3. 4th of July 2007/Mount Rushmore Singers (1,150,110 views) – animation of GVB song
  4. Aaron Wilburn – Krispy Kremes, Men and Women, Funny Names (341,650 views) – Gaither mentioned in description
  5. Fresh Blend Sings Gaither Vocal Band (179,580 views) – local group doing Gaither song

The highest placing concert videos of the respective groups were the Gaither Vocal Band’s “Alpha and Omega,” #6 with 133,717 views and Casting Crowns’ “The Altar and the Door Sneak Preview,” #10 with 187,917 views. However, it appears that Gaither’s video got its views independently, while the Casting Crowns film was posted by their label, and appears to have picked up some of its hits through being viewed on the label’s website.

For more about —and other Southern Gospel news and commentary—follow our RSS feed or sign up for our email updates!

2 Letters to the Editor

Southern Gospel Journal welcomes letters to the editor. We will post the most thoughtful and insightful submissions. Ground rules: Don't attack or belittle groups or fellow posters, or advance heresies rejected by orthodox Christianity. Do keep comments positive, constructive, and on topic.
  1. Hmm…when I type “gaither” on YouTube’s search and sort by view count, I don’t get any of those except the Fresh Blend clip.

  2. Well, I got these the first time I typed in the keyword. The second time I got the results you describe. Then I tried again and got the results I got in the first place. Go figure.