Concert Review: Perrys, Inspirations, Dove Brothers etc. (Franklin, NC)

UPDATE (5/19/2011): We’ve moved the photo gallery from a separate post to the bottom of this post, the original concert report.

On Saturday, I attended the Inspirations’ Fall Colors sing in Franklin, NC. Time does not permit a detailed report, but here are some highlights:

  • The Punches Family, a bluegrass group from Missouri (parents and four children), got a remarkably strong response. Two sons, thirteen and eleven, play the guitar and banjo; the parents play mandolin (father) and upright bass (mother), and the nine-year-old twin daughters play fiddles and sing. While the cuteness factor undoubtedly played a role in the incredibly strong response (even stronger, in fact, than the professional bluegrass group which followed them), there is enough musical talent in the family, incipient and realized, to show promise of a future where their picking and singing alone will bring the house down.
  • Balsam Range, the current group of former Isaacs/Kingsmen member Tim Surrett, got a mostly warm but not rousing response. I say “mostly” because there was one exception: Tim Surrett introduced the song “Wish You Were Here” by saying that he was going to be singing it on Monday (today) for the funeral of a longtime disabled friend who had just passed away. He said that Balsam Range had never sung the song on stage before. This was reinforced by the fact that banjo player Marc Pruett and mandolin player Darren Nicholson stepped back and did not play on the song; fiddler Buddy Melton played a soft, gentle part, Surrett played bass, and guitarist Caleb Smith stepped up and delivered a remarkably perfect guitar part, carrying the rendition. Both because of the introduction and because the audience was more familiar with Kingsmen music than bluegrass music, the song received the strongest response of their set.
  • The Dove Brothers’ three-piece live band brings an energy to their set that is regrettably fairly unique to current Southern Gospel groups—an energy no soundtrack can reproduce. Dixie Melody Boys tenor Jonathan Price was filling in; despite not even having rehearsed with the group prior to stepping on stage, he did an excellent and (at least very close to) flawless job. As a matter of fact, though former tenor Jerry Martin is one of those incredible talents whose shoes in that regard are virtually impossible to fill, Price blends better with lead singer McCray Dove. He was slightly tentative on the first song—slightly enough that it probably took someone who has watched both Price and the Dove Brothers in person before to notice—but delivered a strong performance.
  • Speaking of great blend with a fill-in, the Perrys called their old pianist Matthew Holt out to fill in on baritone for the weekend, following Troy Peach’s departure last week. Holt’s warm baritone tones were an excellent match for his longtime friend and co-writer Joseph Habedank’s warm but more commanding lead vocals—and as a matter of fact, I can say as one who has heard every Perrys lineup since 1984 (pre-Tracy Stuffle) on recording and every lineup since 2004 or 2005 in person that this is the best-matched, tightest Perrys vocal lineup I have ever heard. I am certain that Bryan Walker will be a good vocalist, but I left the concert wishing that somehow Holt, who now runs a college music program, could have been persuaded to stay. The Perrys’ closing song, “If You Knew Him,” got the strongest response of any song all day. The response it received from an audience who came out to hear the Inspirations’ acoustic mountain style leaves no doubt that it was worthy of its “Song of the Year” title.
  • The Inspirations delivered a strong set. New tenor Jodi Hosterman seems to be getting comfortable in his own shoes—it takes a certain amount of courage to take on “Two Shoes” and “Touring That City” in front of an essentially hometown audience who has been listening to Archie Watkins for over four decades. Lead singer David Ragan, meanwhile, is visibly having a great time on stage with this lineup, hitting the high Fs and Gs to keep up with Hosterman’s incredibly high range, and endings that have never before been heard on Inspirations songs. An all-acapella rendition of “That’s Why I Call it Home,” featuring Ragan and baritone singer Melton Campbell, got the strongest response of the Inspirations’ set.

For more about and and and —and other Southern Gospel news and commentary—follow our RSS feed or sign up for our email updates!

8 Letters to the Editor

Southern Gospel Journal welcomes letters to the editor. We will post the most thoughtful and insightful submissions. Ground rules: Don't attack or belittle groups or fellow posters, or advance heresies rejected by orthodox Christianity. Do keep comments positive, constructive, and on topic.
  1. That’s a great review Daniel! wish i could have been there.

  2. It was indeed a great concert and Matt did an awesome job, HOWEVER I love Matt on piano and would love to see him back in a fulltime position as a piano player one day!

  3. Like with any new addition to a group, it takes a little time to adjust to the lineup and the style. Jodi is very good at adapting to whatever style is needed. He is an incredibly high tenor and has one of the cleanest tones. You can always understand him. I agree with you Daniel that the Inspirations are higher now than they have ever been. David is a great lead singer and Melton is amazing at the baritone. Mike, of course, is still the man on the bass. I find it very interesting that the Inspirations recorded “That’s Why I Call It Home” with a track and in live concerts do it acapella. The acapella rendition is absolutely stunning. I like it 10 times better acapella than I do with the track and I loved the song with the track.

    On the Dove Brothers fill in tenor, Jonathan Price is an amazing tenor and I wondered whenever Jerry left if he would be maybe making the move to them. Jonathan has been in the “Ed Oneal University” for a couple of years now and I just expect him to go somewhere big pretty soon. He is just a great singer.

    Great review again Daniel. God bless you brother!

  4. Hello, I am trying to find the name of an incredible guitarist who is going to be playing at a church in Franklin, NC in October. If anyone know s who he is and when and where he’s playing could you respond here. Thanks, Kat

    • This is a rather broad question – I wonder if there is any chance that more that one good guitarist might appear in Franklin, NC at some point this month. 🙂

  5. I”m trying to find the Dove Brother’s sound tract for,We Gotta Love,can anyone help?

    • As that song is from a live album, no soundtrack was created.